MONTREAL (CP) - There's a growing belief that
pregnant women should be receiving key vaccines,
including flu shots, experts say. But two new
studies suggest the health-care professionals they
see most often don't or can't deliver the vaccines
in question.
The studies, by Toronto researchers, found
obstetricians often aren't equipped to give
vaccines and midwives aren't permitted to give
many, including flu shots.
"So now we've said that pregnant women should
be vaccinated, we've got this group of women who
have a primary-care provider who can't vaccinate
them, because influenza vaccine is not on the
list" of drugs midwives can administer, said Dr.
Allison McGeer, one of the authors of the studies.
Even if midwives could give more shots, the
study found they are less enthusiastic about
vaccinations in general than other health-care
providers. More than 40 per cent questioned the
value of influenza vaccine and as a whole the
midwives studied were less likely to get a flu
shot than other health-care providers.
In fact, 22 per cent of them felt a flu shot
was a greater health risk to a pregnant woman than
getting influenza, according to the study, which
was presented at an immunization conference
organized by the Public Health Agency of Canada
and the Canadian Pediatric Society.
The study also found midwives had received
little training about immunization, leaving them
ill-equipped to help teach expectant mothers about
vaccination schedules - even though they can be
the primary caregiver for women who use their
services.
Immunization expert Dr. Ronald Gold said the
group is a weak link in the vaccination chain.
"I think they are," said Gold, who headed the
infectious diseases division at Toronto's Hospital
for Sick Children before he retired in 1996.
"Because they do provide a lot - an increasing
amount - of prenatal care. And that's the time to
begin educating mothers about vaccination. Not
when the baby's two months of age."
Traditionally pregnant women haven't been given
many vaccinations. The thinking was that one
didn't give a pregnant woman anything that wasn't
absolutely necessary, in order to reduce the
potential of risk to the fetus.
But that model is changing. In the United
States, it is recommended pregnant women get a flu
shot. The current Canadian recommendation is that
women who are at risk of bad outcomes from flu -
asthmatics, for instance - should get a shot.
But this year the committee which advises on
immunization policy also urged people who are
household contacts of infants to get a flu shot.
The aim is to put a ring of protection around
children under six months, who are too young to
get flu vaccine but who can become seriously ill
if they catch influenza.
That's virtually a recommendation that pregnant
women get a flu shot, said McGeer, an infectious
diseases specialist at Toronto's Mount Sinai
Hospital. "If you are pregnant . . . you
will become a household contact of a high-risk
individual."
Advisory groups are also considering
recommending pregnant women get pertussis and
Group B strep vaccines, she noted.
This trend led her and her co-authors to
examine who looks after pregnant women and how
likely those professionals are to fill this
function.
The second study, looking at attitudes among
family physicians and obstetricians towards flu
vaccination during pregnancy, found that only 15
per cent of obstetricians felt it was their
responsibility to give their pregnant patients a
flu shot, even though most got a flu shot
themselves, thought the shots worked and knew flu
posed a risk to pregnant women.
Obstetricians haven't been in the business of
giving vaccinations and often don't stock
vaccines, McGeer explained.